A recent breeder discussion brought up a topic I think deserves a little more daylight. There’s still a lot of misunderstanding about what’s legal when it comes to reviews, so I decided to put this together as a quick guide for anyone who might run into it.
Here’s the short version: you can’t legally forbid someone from leaving an honest review.
Those “no negative reviews,” “non-disparagement,” or “gag” clauses that sometimes sneak into kitten contracts? They’re not enforceable.
In fact, they’re specifically prohibited by the Consumer Review Fairness Act (15 U.S.C. § 45b) — a federal law that protects your right to share truthful feedback about any product or service, including a kitten purchase.
That means:
-
A breeder can absolutely ask that you come to them first with concerns — that’s just good communication.
-
But they cannot fine you, penalize you, or threaten legal action for posting an honest, factual review.
-
And if you’ve already signed a contract with that clause, it’s still void.
Most of the time, these clauses appear because someone copied a template without realizing what it meant. Still, it’s worth checking before you sign. If you see one, ask politely for it to be removed. Ethical breeders won’t mind — they stand by their kittens and their reputation.
And while we’re talking about honesty, here’s the other half of the equation:
review rights go both ways.
The same laws that protect honest reviewers don’t protect dishonest ones.
If someone posts something false or intentionally misleading — something they know isn’t true — that can cross into defamation, which is illegal. Truth is always your best protection.
If you stick to verifiable facts (“this happened,” “this was my experience”) instead of assumptions or name-calling, you’ll always be on solid ground.
Quick takeaway:
Transparency protects everyone. Breeders deserve fairness; buyers deserve truth. The law agrees with both.
(If you’d like to read the statute yourself, here’s the link straight from the FTC:
https://www.ftc.gov/legal-library/browse/statutes/consumer-review-fairness-act)
What to Do if You See This in a Contract
If you come across a “no negative reviews” clause, start from a place of goodwill.
Most breeders who include one don’t realize it’s illegal — they’re usually just trying to protect their reputation from unfair attacks.
You can say something like:
“Hey, I just wanted to flag this section about reviews. The FTC’s Consumer Review Fairness Act makes it illegal to ban or penalize honest feedback, so could we please remove or reword that part before signing?”
If they’re open to rewording, a fair and legal alternative might be something like:
“Buyer agrees to communicate any concerns directly to the breeder before posting publicly, so both parties have an opportunity to resolve the issue in good faith.”
That version protects everyone — it encourages direct communication but doesn’t silence truth.
If the breeder refuses to remove the clause or insists it’s enforceable, that’s a red flag. At that point, you can report it to the Federal Trade Commission (FTC), which enforces the Consumer Review Fairness Act, or your state’s consumer protection office.
We all want the same thing: healthy kittens, happy families, and trust that lasts. Clear contracts and honest reviews help us all get there.
